According to PO, the withdrawal of the vessel Manet in 2008 and that of the vessels Cézanne and Renoir cannot count as a contribution since these withdrawals took place well before the notification of the restructuring and the value of the vessels is minimal compared to the total amount of the State aid, i.e. EUR 400 million, according to PO.
Selon PO, le retrait du navire Manet en 2008 et celui des navires Cézanne et Renoir ne sauraient compter comme contribution puisque ces retraits ont eu lieu bien avant la notification de la restructuration et que la valeur des navires est minime comparée au montant total des aides d’État, soit 400 millions EUR selon PO.