Hon. Noël A. Kinsella (Deputy Leader of the Opposition): Honourable senators, the crux of the matter as to whether or not the privileges of this house have been breached turn very much in part on the citation that Senator Murray has drawn our attention to from Erskine May's 19th Edition. I will just repeat it, at page 155, Your Honour, where it says:
L'honorable Noël A. Kinsella (leader adjoint de l'opposition): Honorables sénateurs, le coeur de la question pour ce qui est de déterminer s'il y a eu ou non atteinte aux privilèges du Sénat repose en grande partie sur la citation tirée de la page 155 de la 19édition d'Erskine May, que le sénateur Murray a portée à notre attention.